Cinema Eye - Movie News & Reviews
Untitled Page

Under the Same Moon (2008)


Weekend Box Office Director: Patricia Riggen
Cast: Kate Del Castillo, Adrian Alonso, Eugenio Derbez
Country: USA/Mexico
Year: 2008
Score: **
MPAA Rating:

The plot of UNDER THE SAME MOON can be summed up in one line.  Mexican boy (Adrian Alonso) crosses border to unite with his mother working illegally in the U.S.  Director Patricia Riggen’s entire film, based on the script by Ligiah Villaobos goes through the painful process, ensuring no cliché is left unturned of the mother and son reunion.  Other characters in the story include a loving but ill grandmother, wicked aunt and uncle and a reluctant guardian, Enrique (Eugenio Derbez).  Surprisingly, Riggen holds back on the tears but that does not mean the film fares any better.

From the very start, mother Rosario (Kate Del Castillo) circles on her calendar the date of Carlitos’ birthday.  Every Sunday, she calls him and they go through the ‘we love each other’ procedure till the telephone connection is cut when coins run out.  The two bond seeing each other through the reflection of the moon.  Enough mush is enough!  But the film at least is not boring as the script keeps piling on incident after incident (crazy though it might seem) before the boy, undoubtedly and predictably succeeds in his quest.

The script fails to establish a strong reason for Rosario to leave her son to work in the States.  The only time the film gets grounded in reality is when the narrative fails in its credibility.  Some suspense is generated when Carlitos is smuggled across the border.  One wishes the film’s two most interesting characters Dona Carmen (Carmen Solinas) and Rosario’s bitchy American employer, Mrs. McKenzie (Jacqueline Voltaire) were given more screen time.

UNDER THE SAME MOON is filmed in English and (Mexican) Spanish.  Most of the nasties on illegal immigration and racial prejudice are lightened making the film family friendly.


Review by: Gilbert Seah

No Responses to Under the Same Moon

Why don't you leave one?

Leave a Comment

Remember me.
Submit the word you see below:


Recent News Recent News

Burma Cyclone Relief Benefit Screening
Weekend Box Office (May 9-11) Estimates
This Week's Film Reviews (May 10)
Cinematheque Ontario - J'Entends plus la Guitare
New DVD Titles Out Soon
Weekend Box Office (Mar 2-4) Estimates
This Week's Film Reviews (May 2)
Opening The Week of Apr 18th

Recent News Current Reviews

Son of Rambow
Redbelt
My Blueberry Nights
The Babysitters
The Stone Angel
An Unknown Woman
Speed Racer
What Happens in Vegas
J'Entends plus la Guitare
14 Days in Paradise
War, Inc.
Fugitive Pieces
Standard Operating Procedure
Iron Man
Then She Found Me
The Singing Revolution
Ben X
The Forbidden Kingdom
88 Minutes
London to Brighton
Emotional Arithmetic
Bella
Chaos Theory
Sex and Death 101
Leatherheads
Cinema Eye >> Movie News | Movie Reviews | Forums | Asian Fever | Information
Archives >> News | Reviews | Site
EYEBALL media network Eat Football | Cinema Eye | Home Cinema Reviews | Gameheads | Joe Bartender
RSS FEED | JohnQ Internet TV
© 1998-2007, Cinema Eye, All rights reserved | Contact CinemaEye