Cinema Eye - Movie News & Reviews
Untitled Page
  Top Links
Top Picks DVD Rental
Top Picks Home Cinema
Top Picks Broadband
Top Picks BlueRay
Top Picks Ringtones
Top Picks Gifts
Top Picks Casino
Top Picks DVD
Top Picks Plasma TV

Mongol (2008)


Weekend Box Office Director: Sergei Bodrov
Cast: Asano Tadanobu, Khulan Chuluun
Country: Russ/Kaza/China/Mongolia 2007
Year: 2008
Score: **
MPAA Rating:

Set in the 12th century in the Tangkut Kingdom, the film MONGOL follows the life of a young Genghis Khan the famous conqueror known then as Temudgin. Temudgin is portrayed by Japanese actor Asano Tadanobu (ZATOICHI) with a fair amount of screen time dealing his romance with his spirited bride Borte (Khulan Chuluun).  Strangely, the film works more effectively as a romance than an action flick.

Director Sergei Bodrov is no stranger to both lavish productions and intimate stories having directed Catherine Deneuve in EAST-WEST and the quiet drama PRISONER OF THE MOUNTAINS.  The cinematography, action sequences and romantic sequences of MONGOL work well.  But it is the continuity that is the nagging problem.  In one scene, the audience is treated to a fight between a dozen or so enemies and in the next set a year later, there are literally hundreds of thousands of troops (no doubt generated by CGI) ready for battle.  Where do these people come from and how were they recruited?  MONGOL boasts historical accuracy - the film is supposedly based on scholarly accounts.  Bodrov also reveals only at the end that Temudgin is Genghis Khan.  Why then do the ads proudly state that this is the untold story of Genghis Khan if the revelation is supposed to be kept secret?  Different languages spoken from Mongolian to Mandarin add some authenticity. 

MONGOL also dispels belief that one man kept in a cage could suddenly emerge fighting and killing off his enemies.  The scene of the rich Chinese buyer opposing the advice of an old monk implies a re-visit to this scene though this never happens.

Another problem is that Bodrov never connects the audience to Temudgin’s plight.  For one, he is shown mainly as a brute.  When shown later on to care for children and women, the question of his disloyalty to his initial brother and enemy, Jamukha (Honglei Sun) in stealing of his men emphasizes more of a conflict of his character.

MONGOL emerges as a feast for the eyes in scenes set in places most audiences are unfamiliar with (like the Mongolian steppes).  But the story is un-engaging and nobody really cares whether Temudgen’s fate at most points in the movie.  MONGOL was nominated for this year’s Oscar for Best Foreign Film.


Review by: Gilbert Seah

2 Responses to Mongol

  1. Joe McCarthy Says:

    I am sadly disappointed by your analysis of the movie.
    The cinematography alone was worth the price of admission. Temudgin’s father was not Kublai Khan. Kublai Khan was his grandson, who expanded the empire created by Temudgin’s early efforts to unite the Mongol tribes which he did successfully. The movie allowed us to see the personal side (imagined I suspect) of the great conquerer which had wit, and love, along with the strong killer instinct
    of the time.  I personally would give it 4 out of 5 stars.

  2. Gilbert Seah Says:

    Dear Joe,

    Thanks for you honest comment.  Agree with you that cinematography was excellent.  I should have checked about Kublai being Genghis father.  I remembered wrong from my History lesson, I guessed and I just asked a friend who also thought Kublai was his father.  Corrected the point in the review and thanks for pointing out error.

Leave a Comment

Remember me.
Submit the word you see below:


Recent News Recent News

Opening the Week of Feb 10
TIFF BELL Lightbox - Robert Bresson
Docs Soup March -Calvert (Review)
Free Film Weekend at Tiff Bell Lightbox
Opening the Week of Feb 3
Best Bets of the Week
NFB - (Jan 31 - Feb 6th)
AVENGERS Assemble on Twitter

Recent News Current Reviews

Journey 2: Mysterious Island
We Need to Talk about Kevin
Les Neiges du Kilimandjaro
Norwegian Wood
Chronicle
Big Miracle
Albert Nobbs
Moon Point
Le Vendeur
The Woman in Black
The Innkeepers
Miss Bala
Monsieur Lazhar
Tyrannossaur
Man on a Ledge
The Grey
A Separation
In the Land of Blood and Honey
Haywire
The Divide
Corialanus
Red Tails
The Iron Lady
A Dangerous Method
The Swell Season
Cinema Eye >> Movie News | Movie Reviews | Forums | Asian Fever | Information
Archives >> News | Reviews | Site
EYEBALL media network  | Cinema Eye | Home Cinema Reviews
RSS FEED
© 1998-2009, Cinema Eye, All rights reserved | Contact CinemaEye